Europe & UK

October 12, 2017

Petition for assistance to die rejected: HC of Justice


 high court UK

On October 12, the High Court of Justice rejected a terminally ill individual's petition for assistance to die, upholding the Suicide Act 1961, which makes it illegal to assist in suicide.

Noel Conway, suffering from terminal motor neurone disease, contended that the Suicide Act 1961 is in conflict with Article 8 of the Human Rights Act of 1998 by undermining his right to respect of private and family life through a blanket ban on assisted suicide. Opposing counsel however argued that the act satisfied section 2 of Article 8 as "necessary in a democratic society" as a proportionate measure "for the protection of health," for the protection of morals" and "for the protection of the rights of others."

The court ruled that the act was necessary "to protect the weak and vulnerable":

As the conscience of the nation, Parliament is entitled to maintain in place a clear bright-line rule which forbids people from providing assistance to an individual to commit suicide. Parliament was and is entitled to decide that the clarity of such a moral position could only be achieved by means of such a rule. Although views about this vary in society, we think that the legitimacy of Parliament deciding to maintain such a clear line that people should not seek to intervene to hasten the death of a human is not open to serious doubt. Parliament is entitled to make the assessment that it should protect moral standards in society by issuing clear and unambiguous laws which reflect and embody such standards. The prohibition in section 2 achieves a fair balance between the interests of the wider community and the interests of people in the position of Mr Conway.

Related Post

latest News

  • #INXMedia case: ED's plea against Karti Chidambaram to be heard: SC

    On April 2, the Supreme Court will hear the plea filed by Enforcement Directorate (ED) against Karti Chidambaram, in the INX media money laundering ca...

    Read More
  • Kaleshwaram project issue sent back to NGT: Telangana and AP HC

    Hearing a petition filed by the Telangana government, the Telangana and Andhra Pradesh High Court remanded the matter back to the Principal Bench of N...

    Read More
  • Delhi HC Laments Increasing Instances Of Dishonest Litigation In Country

    On July 28, the Delhi High Court lamented the increasing instances of dishonest litigation in the country, and dismissed an appeal with costs of Rs 2 ...

    Read More