• Advertise
  • Membership
  • Sign inSUBSCRIBE
Legal Era
X
Sign in
  • Home
  • News
    +
    • From the Courts
    • Policy & Law
    • Supreme Court (India)
    • High Court (India)
    • TAX Updates
    • MARKET WATCH
    • Deal Street
    • Global Insights
    • IBC Cases
    • Hires & Moves
    • IP News
    • Competition Verdict
  • Articles
    +
    • ABOUT THE LAW
    • AWARDS & ACCOLADES
    • Aerospace
    • Agriculture
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution
    • Banking and Finance
    • Bankruptcy
    • Book Review
    • Bribery & Corruption
    • Commercial Litigation
    • Competition Law
    • Conference Reports
    • Consumer Products
    • Contract
    • Corporate Governance
    • Corporate Law
    • Covid-19
    • Cryptocurrency
    • Cybersecurity
    • Data Protection
    • Defence
    • Digital Economy
    • E-commerce
    • Employment Law
    • Energy and Natural Resources
    • Entertainment and Sports Law
    • Environmental Law
    • FDI
    • Food and Beverage
    • Health Care
    • IBC Diaries
    • Insurance Law
    • Intellectual Property
    • International Law
    • Labour Laws
    • Litigation
    • Litigation Funding
    • Manufacturing
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • NFTs
    • Privacy
    • Private Equity
    • Project Finance
    • Real Estate
    • Risk and Compliance
    • Technology Media and Telecom
    • Tributes
    • Zoom In
    • Take On Board
    • In Focus
    • Law & Policy and Regulation
    • IP & Tech Era
    • Viewpoint
    • Arbitration & Mediation
    • Tax
    • Student Corner
  • Law Firms
  • In-House
  • Rankings
  • E-Magazine
  • Legal Era TV
  • Events
  • News
    • From the Courts
    • Policy & Law
    • Supreme Court (India)
    • High Court (India)
    • TAX Updates
    • MARKET WATCH
    • Deal Street
    • Global Insights
    • IBC Cases
    • Hires & Moves
    • IP News
    • Competition Verdict
  • Articles
    • ABOUT THE LAW
    • AWARDS & ACCOLADES
    • Aerospace
    • Agriculture
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution
    • Banking and Finance
    • Bankruptcy
    • Book Review
    • Bribery & Corruption
    • Commercial Litigation
    • Competition Law
    • Conference Reports
    • Consumer Products
    • Contract
    • Corporate Governance
    • Corporate Law
    • Covid-19
    • Cryptocurrency
    • Cybersecurity
    • Data Protection
    • Defence
    • Digital Economy
    • E-commerce
    • Employment Law
    • Energy and Natural Resources
    • Entertainment and Sports Law
    • Environmental Law
    • FDI
    • Food and Beverage
    • Health Care
    • IBC Diaries
    • Insurance Law
    • Intellectual Property
    • International Law
    • Labour Laws
    • Litigation
    • Litigation Funding
    • Manufacturing
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • NFTs
    • Privacy
    • Private Equity
    • Project Finance
    • Real Estate
    • Risk and Compliance
    • Technology Media and Telecom
    • Tributes
    • Zoom In
    • Take On Board
    • In Focus
    • Law & Policy and Regulation
    • IP & Tech Era
    • Viewpoint
    • Arbitration & Mediation
    • Tax
    • Student Corner
  • Law Firms
  • In-House
  • Rankings
  • E-Magazine
  • Legal Era TV
  • Events

Top Stories

  • Debashree-Dutta
    Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas advised
  • Trilegal
    Trilegal advised Muthoot Finance
  • SAM
    Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas advised
  • Sippy
    Delhi High Court rules on Trademark Law
  • Stovekraft
    Arya Mathew joins Stovekraft as a
  • Punjab-and-Haryana-High-Court
    Punjab and Haryana High Court repeals
  • Sahara
    Supreme Court sets aside Delhi High
  • NCLAT
    NCLAT urges IBBI to consider modifying
  • Insurance
    Supreme Court directs insurance
  • Supreme Court terms copyright infringement a non-bailable offence
    Supreme Court terms copyright
HomeNewsFrom the Courts
9 Jan 2022 2:30 PM GMT

Supreme Court orders reasonable assessment of fee by NCLT

By: Nilima Pathak
Supreme Court orders reasonable assessment of fee by NCLT

Supreme Court orders reasonable assessment of fee by NCLT The Supreme Court has held that the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) must make a reasonable assessment of the fees and expenses payable to the Interim Resolution Professional (IRP). It cannot pass an order in an ad-hoc manner. Else, it would amount to abdication. A bench of Justice D Y Chandrachud and Justice A S...

ToRead the Full Story, Subscribe to Legal Era

Access the exclusive LEGAL ERAStories,Editorial and Expert Opinion

Subscribe Now
AlreadyaSubscriber?SigninNow
View Plans


Supreme Court orders reasonable assessment of fee by NCLT

The Supreme Court has held that the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) must make a reasonable assessment of the fees and expenses payable to the Interim Resolution Professional (IRP). It cannot pass an order in an ad-hoc manner. Else, it would amount to abdication.

A bench of Justice D Y Chandrachud and Justice A S Bopanna delivered the judgment. It was deliberating on a dispute related to the payment of costs and expenses incurred by an RP, The court set aside the impugned order and the judgment of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) that awarded an ad-hoc amount to the IRP without any consideration of the actual amount due as per the technical and financial bid.

The appellant had been appointed as IRP by an order of NCLT. But, the order was set-aside in the appeal to the NCLAT. The proceedings were remitted to NCLT to decide upon the fees and costs incurred by the appellant to be borne by the respondent (the financial creditor).

The appellant submitted before the Supreme Court that the statement of fee and expenses was in terms of the technical and financial bid. It was claimed that neither NCLAT nor NCLT had conducted any scrutiny of the factual position and merely awarded an ad hoc figure. The appellant argued that there was no application of mind by the adjudicating authorities to the basis of the claim and the figures accepted by the financial creditor.

The top court noted the fact that the appellant had addressed a letter to the respondent in 2019, prior to the filing of the application to which the respondent replied in 2020. The latter had stated that upon verification the cost and fee were found in conformity with both the technical and financial bid.

It also maintained that in the application the appellant annexed a statement of costs, the amount that was reimbursed with the balance dues. Noting that despite the respondent verifying that the costs and fees claimed by the appellant were in conformity with the technical and financial bid, the order of the NCLT had not considered the submission of the appellant.

While noting that both orders "suffered from an abdication in the exercise of the jurisdiction," the apex court remanded it back to NCLT for fresh consideration of the matter.

Click to download here Full Judgment

Nilima Pathak

Nilima Pathak

TAGS:
  • Supreme Court 
  • National Company Law Tribunal 
  • National Company Law Appellate Tribunal 
  • Justice DY Chandrachud 
  • Justice AS Bopanna 
Next Story
Similar Posts
See More
Trending Now
XXXXXXX

XXXXXXX

Power of Magistrate to direct FIR registration & proper investigation under Section 156(3) of Cr.PC

Power of Magistrate to direct FIR registration & proper

Manufacturing Risks Associated with The Nascent Indian EV Industry

Manufacturing Risks Associated with The Nascent Indian EV

Tax on Alimony

Tax on Alimony

Recommended Articles
Arbitration and Commercial Courts: A Jurisdictional Conflict

Arbitration and Commercial Courts: A Jurisdictional Conflict

Multiplicity of Arbitral Proceedings in India

Multiplicity of Arbitral Proceedings in India

Copyright and Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs)

Copyright and Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs)

Renewed Interest in Quincecare Duty of Care in Claims Against Banks

Renewed Interest in Quincecare Duty of Care in Claims

  • News
  • From the Courts
  • Supreme Court (India)
  • High Court (India)
  • Global Insights
  • Deal Street
  • Hires & Moves
  • Refund & Cancellation Policy
  • Articles
  • Zoom In
  • Take On Board
  • In Focus
  • Law & Policy
  • IP & Tech Era
  • Viewpoint
  • Arbitration & Mediation
  • Tax
  • Student Corner
  • Interviews
  • Law Firms
  • E-Magazine
  • Legal Era TV
  • Membership
  • Reader's Feedback
  • Cartoons
  • Subscribe
Follow Us
Subscribe Newsletter
  • 2022© All rights reserved Legal Era Media Group
  • Who We Are
  • Careers
  • Advertise with Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
Powered by  Hocalwire
X
X